If you’ve been searching for “Stonegate homeowners insurance,” you’ve probably noticed something odd: the search results are a mess of auto insurance pages, complaint boards, and third-party quote sites — but not much that clearly answers “does Stonegate sell homeowners insurance, and is it any good?” Let’s fix that.
Who Is Stonegate Insurance, Really?
Stonegate Insurance Company is one of three member companies under Producers National Corporation, a holding company headquartered in Niles, Illinois, that’s been around since 1996 (the other two are Unique Insurance Company and Lighthouse Casualty Company). Stonegate is licensed to write coverage in a handful of states, and it operates almost entirely through independent agents rather than direct online quoting — there’s no “get an instant quote” button on their own site. You can visit Stonegate Insurance’s official website directly to connect with an independent agent in your area.
Here’s the part that trips a lot of homeowners up: Stonegate is best known as a personal and commercial auto insurer in Illinois and Arizona. Its “home” product isn’t a traditional homeowners policy for a single-family house — it’s mobile and manufactured home insurance, available in Florida and Arizona. So if you own a stick-built house and you’re hoping for a standard HO-3 policy, Stonegate probably isn’t the carrier you’re looking for. If you own a manufactured or mobile home in FL or AZ, it might actually be relevant to you — but you’ll need to go through an independent agent to find out.
Does Stonegate Offer Traditional Homeowners Coverage?
Not really, and it’s worth being upfront about that. Stonegate’s public-facing information is thin, which is a recurring complaint across nearly every review site that covers them — including their own website, which offers very little detail about products, eligibility, or pricing without talking to an agent first. What we do know:
- Mobile/manufactured home coverage is offered in Florida and Arizona.
- Coverage is arranged through independent agents, not sold directly online.
- Policy terms and available discounts aren’t published anywhere consumers can easily browse.
If you’re comparing “homeowners insurance” in the conventional sense — dwelling coverage, personal property, loss of use, liability, medical payments — you’ll want to confirm directly with an agent whether Stonegate’s manufactured home product includes those standard components, since the details simply aren’t published for public comparison the way they are with larger national carriers.
How Stonegate Stacks Up on Reputation
This is where most people’s real question lives: is this company trustworthy? A few data points worth knowing:
- BBB customer reviews: Stonegate holds a low average customer review score with the Better Business Bureau, even though the company itself is BBB-accredited (accreditation reflects business practices and responsiveness to complaints, not customer satisfaction — the two are different things and easy to conflate).
- NAIC complaint index: The National Association of Insurance Commissioners tracks a “complaint index” that compares how many complaints a company receives relative to its size. Stonegate’s index has come in below average, meaning it receives fewer formal regulatory complaints than would be expected for a company of its size — a genuinely positive signal, even if it doesn’t match the tone of some of the more dramatic customer reviews you’ll find elsewhere.
- BBB complaint history: Over a recent three-year period, the company logged 17 complaints, most centered on claims handling, billing/refund timing, and communication delays. A recurring theme in customer accounts is difficulty reaching an adjuster promptly and confusion around refund checks after a policy cancellation.
None of that automatically means “avoid this company.” Every insurer with enough policyholders accumulates complaints, and billing hiccups happen industry-wide. But it does mean Stonegate isn’t a carrier with a strong, well-documented reputation for homeowners-style products the way a State Farm or Travelers is — so going in with your eyes open, and getting everything in writing, is a smart move.
What Is the Claims Process for Stonegate Insurance?
Based on how the company describes its own process and how customers report their experiences, filing a claim with Stonegate generally follows this pattern:
- Report the loss. You (or your independent agent) contact Stonegate’s claims department directly, typically by phone, as soon as possible after the incident.
- Claim number and adjuster assignment. Stonegate opens a claim file and assigns an adjuster to investigate.
- Documentation. You’ll be asked to submit supporting evidence — photos, repair estimates, a police report if applicable, and any other paperwork tied to the loss.
- Adjuster review and decision. The adjuster evaluates the claim against your policy terms and issues a coverage determination.
- Payment or denial. If approved, payment is issued according to your policy limits and deductible; if denied, you have the right to appeal or escalate.
Several customer complaints on record describe slower-than-expected adjuster response times and difficulty getting a straight answer on payment amounts or timelines. If you do file a claim with Stonegate, it’s worth keeping your own written log of every call, and following up in writing (email) whenever possible so there’s a paper trail.
What Not to Tell Your Insurance Company
Regardless of which insurer you’re dealing with, there are a few things worth being careful about when you’re on the phone with any claims adjuster — Stonegate included:
- Don’t guess at fault or speculate about cause. Stick to what you directly observed; let the investigation determine fault.
- Don’t admit blame casually. A conversational “I probably should have…” can get read as an admission and used against your claim.
- Don’t exaggerate damages or losses. Overstating a claim, even unintentionally, can trigger denial or even fraud investigations.
- Don’t accept a lowball settlement on the spot. You’re allowed to ask for time to review an offer, get an independent estimate, or consult an attorney before agreeing to anything.
- Don’t give a recorded statement without understanding your rights. You can ask what it’s for and whether you’re required to provide one.
None of this means being cagey or dishonest — full documentation and honesty always work in your favor. It just means answering what’s asked, not volunteering interpretation, opinion, or speculation.
Which Homeowners Insurance Has the Most Complaints?
This varies year to year and by state, since complaint volume is influenced by how many policies a company writes, not just how badly it behaves. The NAIC’s complaint index is the standard tool for comparing companies fairly, because it adjusts for company size — a large national insurer with thousands of complaints might actually have a lower complaint ratio than a small regional carrier with only a handful. If you’re comparison shopping, look up any insurer’s current NAIC complaint index and your state insurance department’s consumer complaint database rather than relying on raw review counts, which can be skewed by a small number of very vocal customers.
Who Is StoneWood Insurance Services?
This is a genuinely common mix-up, given how close the names sound — but Stonewood Insurance Services is a completely different company from Stonegate Insurance. Stonewood was a California-based general agency that specialized in non-standard personal auto coverage, and it was acquired by Confie Seguros back in 2012. There’s also a separate, unrelated Stonewood Insurance Company that underwrites workers’ compensation insurance in southeastern and midwestern states. Neither of these entities has any corporate connection to Stonegate Insurance Company or Producers National Corporation — they just happen to share a similar-sounding name, which trips up a lot of online searches.
Conclusion
If you’re a manufactured or mobile homeowner in Florida or Arizona, Stonegate might be worth a conversation with a local independent agent — just go in knowing the company publishes very little online, works exclusively through agents, and has a mixed track record on claims communication. If you own a traditional single-family home, Stonegate’s product lineup likely isn’t built for you, and you’ll get more transparency (and probably more coverage options) by comparing quotes from carriers that specialize in standard homeowners policies. Either way, the smartest move before binding any policy — Stonegate or otherwise — is to ask directly for the coverage details in writing, confirm exactly what’s included and excluded, and check your state’s insurance department complaint records for yourself.
Also Read: Gap Insurance for New Trucks: Protect Your Investment and Finances Today!